Investigative Report

The Mystery of the Lighthouse at Ballyfermot Library

The Investigation Process

Listening to the introductory talk

Investigating the evidence

Documenting theories and responses

After listening to the introductory talk, young investigators assessed clues, evidence and the lighthouse itself before casting their vote or sharing their theory.

Pie Chart: All Votes

Analysis of “Your Own Theory”

  • Common sense responses, offering practical explanations for strange events; comas, dreams, disguised neighbours.

  • The lighthouse and/or the house in the story are haunted by a ghost. Possibly a ghost who wants the family to leave, or the ghost of the father.

  • Budding writers and creative thinkers with fantastically creative theories.

  • A secret code for spies is contained within the lighthouse or the clues/evidence in the room.

Conclusion

The lead investigation team were truly impressed by the level of enthusiasm and creativity they observed in the younger investigators at Ballyfermot. All theories were considered.

Based on the available evidence, the votes and theories, the lead investigation team were split between two most likely scenarios…

1

Something unusual did happen in a house in Ballyfermot in the 1960s, something strange enough that it was remembered years later in gossip and stories. That someone in Eithne’s family (probably her mother Mrs F) created the model lighthouse with the light on top and the tiny lighthouse inside — a double lighthouse — to make the children feel safe in the dark at night. Maybe the double lighthouse had some sort of power that protected the family and the little house in Ballyfermot, but it’s unlikely we’ll ever know exactly what happened in the house that winter.

2

Further investigation of the interior and base of the lighthouse at the library showed it could have been a very creative model for a real lighthouse at Ballyfermot, perhaps planned for the centre of the roundabout. Its sweeping beam of light would have come on each evening at the same time as the street lights to help lift the heavy dark from the surrounding area. The bright light would add to the street lights making sure people, motorists and cyclists had enough light to safely move around at night. The old photos we found showing a real lighthouse at Ballyfermot, could have been created for part of the planning permission for the lighthouse.

These are two possible theories, but until some new evidence comes to light we might never discover the true origin of the lighthouse at Ballyfermot library. Investigations are ongoing.